Montessori vs. Traditional Preschool: Practical Differences in a Child Care Setting - post

What is Montessori #preschool in simple words?

Montessori is a child- #centered approach. Children #learn by choosing hands-on work from shelves and using real materials. The #teacher guides and observes, but children do much of the “doing” themselves.

In many Montessori-style #classrooms, you will notice:

• Children working in small groups or alone
• Longer blocks of uninterrupted time (often called a work cycle)
• Materials placed on low, open shelves
• A strong focus on independence (children help themselves and help the classroom)

If you want a clear intro that helps you explain Montessori to families and staff, the course Intro to Montessori: Philosophy, Principles, and Practices is a helpful starting point: 

What does a “traditional preschool” usually look like in child care? 

Traditional preschool can vary a lot, but it often includes:

• Whole-group circle time
• Teacher-chosen #centers (art, blocks, dramatic play)
• A shorter activity time before switching to the next part of the schedule
• More worksheets, #crafts, and teacher-led projects (depending on the program)

Many traditional classrooms still use play-based learning and best practices. The big difference is often who decides what happens next—the teacher or the child.

For providers who want guidance on age-appropriate practice often used in traditional settings, this course is a good match: DAP for Preschool 

How is the daily schedule different in Montessori vs. traditional preschool?

This is one of the first differences you will feel as a provider.

Montessori schedule (common pattern):

• Longer work periods (often #2– #3-hours in the morning)
• Fewer transitions
• Children choose work and repeat it until they feel done

Traditional preschool schedule (common pattern):

• Shorter center times
• More group activities led by the teacher
• More transitions (circle time, centers, snack, outside, story, etc.)

Why it #matters in child care:
Transitions can be a hard time for behavior. Fewer transitions often means fewer behavior problems. More transitions can still work well, but it usually requires stronger routines and more adult direction.

What is the biggest #classroom-setup difference you can see right away?

In Montessori, the room is designed to help children do things without constant adult help. This is often called the prepared environment. 

In a Montessori-style setup, you will often see:

• One of each material (so children practice waiting and turn-taking)
• Child-sized tools (small pitchers, brooms, trays)
• Clean, simple shelves with materials organized by area
• Real-life activities (pouring, washing, sorting, practical life)

In a traditional setup, you may see:

• More toys with lots of pieces
• More themed decorations and teacher-made dis #plays
• Center areas that change often (weekly themes, rotating toys)

What is the teacher’s role in Montessori vs. traditional preschool?

This is another major difference.

In Montessori, the teacher often:

• Observes and takes notes
• Gives short, clear lessons to individuals or small groups
• Helps children solve problems with materials and with friends
• Protects long work time (so children can focus)

In traditional preschool, the teacher often:

• Leads whole-group lessons and activities
• Sets up and rotates centers
• Guides children through group projects
• Uses the schedule to keep the day moving

In a child care setting, both roles matter. You still need safe supervision, warm relationships, and clear routines—no matter the style.

How is behavior guidance different in Montessori vs. traditional preschool?

Both approaches can be kind and #respectful. The tools are often different.

Montessori guidance often uses:

• Clear limits (protecting people and materials)
• Natural and logical consequences (misuse = material is put away and re-taught)
• Grace and courtesy lessons (teaching how to greet, ask for a turn, apologize)
• Calm, consistent teacher responses

Traditional guidance often uses:

• Class rules posted and reviewed as a group
• Group reminders and behavior charts (depending on the program)
• Whole-group lessons about feelings and friendship skills
• Reward systems (stickers, tokens) in some programs

A very Montessori-friendly tool that can also work in traditional classrooms is a calm-down space. ChildCareEd’s #free resource Peace Corner gives ideas for a quiet area that supports self-regulation:

You can share it with your team as you talk about behavior supports. 

Do Montessori classrooms have play, or is it all “work”?

Montessori teachers often call activities “work,” but for young children, it is still joyful and #playful. The difference is that Montessori “work” is usually:

• Hands-on and purposeful
• Focused on real skills (pouring, sorting, building, matching)
• Designed to build attention and independence

Traditional preschool play can be:

• More open-ended dramatic play and group games
• More teacher-planned crafts and themed activities
• More large-group songs and movement

In child care, you can support both by offering:

• A mix of open-ended play and purposeful hands-on tasks
• Outdoor time and #gross-motor play every day 
• Choice, but with clear limits

What about mixed-age groups in child care—does Montessori fit?

Montessori often uses mixed-age groups on purpose (like 3–6 years together). Many child care programs already have mixed ages, especially in smaller centers or family child care #homes.

Potential benefits of mixed ages (Montessori-style):

• Younger children learn by watching older children 
• Older children practice #leadership and helping
• Less competition, more community

Common challenge:

• You need clear rules for safety (small parts, climbing, active #play-areas)

A simple tip: create “yes spaces” for each age level (safe choices they can access without you saying “no” all day).

How can you explain Montessori vs. traditional to families without arguing?

Families may feel worried if something looks unfamiliar. Keep it simple and positive.

Try saying:

• “Both styles #support-learning. Montessori uses more child choice and hands-on materials.”
• “In Montessori, children practice independence. In traditional preschool, teachers lead more group activities.”
• “Our goal is the same: safe, #happy children who are learning every day.”

For a helpful ChildCareEd read that supports this conversation, you can share: Montessori Education: A Comprehensive Overview

How can a child care program blend Montessori and traditional preschool in a practical way?

You do not have to choose only one style. Many child care programs blend.

Here are realistic “Monday morning” steps:

• Put 6–10 activities on open shelves ( #puzzles, sorting, pouring, matching)
• Use trays or baskets so children can carry work to a table or rug
• Offer longer choice time (even adding 20–30 minutes helps!)
• Teach 1 grace-and-courtesy lesson each week (how to wait, how to ask, how to clean up)
• Reduce transitions when you can (combine activities, simplify the schedule)

This kind of blending can improve focus and reduce chaos—without changing your entire program overnight. 

Want more Montessori tips and support?

For weekly ideas and quick training updates, follow ChildCareEd here and choose your favorite platform: https://linktr.ee/childcareed.